Thorns FC: Goals change games. LOTS of games.

Carlisle-sensei gets the last word on the improbable 1-nil home win over The Damned Courage last Sunday:

“We had an absolute thunderblast from Marie Müller that secured playoff spots for four (4!) teams. If we were gonna get one goal to drain most of the drama from Decision Day at least it was that one.”

Yep. Mmhm. Okay. I won’t argue that. That was one hell of a goal.

Which is good, because before that goal watching this one was kinda like an hour of…

…that.

Oh, don’t get me wrong. Some people (coughReilynTurnercough) did some soccery things, including getting a crack in the 5th minute (that Kailen Sheridan had to come out strong to block), running onto a long Marie Muller lob in the 13th minute (but without controlling the ball until the Carolina defenders closed her down), and then four minutes later collecting a tidy cross from a long Carolyn Calzada attacking run (but, again, holding the shot too long and giving the Damned time to get bodies in front to block it).

Then?

Well…kinda lots of foozling around from both sides.

Carolina didn’t have any ideas beyond “find Ashley Sanchez and hope she can score somehow” which might have worked had they had anyone helping her out, which they mostly didn’t, or if their direct play managed to stay onside, which it mostly didn’t, or the Thorns defense had been ignoring her enough to give her good looks, which they mostly didn’t.

Portland, meanwhile, didn’t have much of anything once Turner kind of ran out of gas around the half hour. Worked some corner kicks (nothing doing, which we’ll discuss). Caiya Hanks put in a couple of clever runs, but since the attack was mostly single spies the Damned defense battalions swarmed and disarmed them. The goal came out of what looked like just one more failed attack, with Turner’s shot blocked, but then – I’d call it “against the run of play” except there hadn’t been a whole lot of run of play for either team – Muller ran on to the rebound and stonked it past Sheridan.

For the final half hour it was just a matter of white-knuckling the match to the whistle, parking the bus again and denying Sanchez the equalizer.

Credit where it’s due; Coach Vilahamn clearly set his Thorns up to 1) isolate Sanchez, which they did, and 2) defend in depth and as a unit, which they also did.

Against Carolina, who’ve been scoring in batches, that seemed kinda scary to me, but, hey, it worked. Carolina had all of the ball, worked it around and around and did nothing (or next to nothing) with it, a brilliant display of “possession without purpose”.

Portland defended and (every so often) countered, but the other Thorns season-long issue that showed up again (failure to finish) meant that despite grinding out a decent-looking xG (1.15 by halftime, 2.01 by the final whistle) managed to put only five of their 13 shots on frame (2 misses, 6 blocks) and converted just the one. I’m gonna bet the xGOT or post-shot xG or whatever you call it was barely over 1.0.

Update 10/29: Thanks to Friend of the Rivet Irene for digging up the FOTMOB hard xGOT/PS-xG numbers: “Portland 0.55, Carolina 0.78”. So not even 1.0; more like half of that. Which is a reminder that the “overperforming xG/PS-xG” has been a feature of Portland’s attack this season, and this was no exception…which makes me less sanguine about Coach Vilahamn’s plan to rope-a-dope The Damned.

But what a one that was.

So we’re in. Safely above the red line no matter what happens in the fever swamps of Houston this coming weekend.

Then we’re in the World of Playoff Soccer, where none of the old rules apply.

Short Passes

Here’s Sofascore’s “attacking momentum” plot:

What’s interesting is how well this reflects the way the match looked on the field. Portland with few attacks, spaced out in time, but with “big chances” when they came. The two tall green spikes in the first half are probably two of the three Turner chances discussed above. I’m guessing the one in the second half is the only real buildup the Thorns assembled after halftime, a 69th minute passing series that produced a Muller shot (blocked) that rebounded to Reyna Reyes for another shot (blocked) that looped back to Muller who shot right at Sheridan.

Going the other way? Carolina had a string of half-chances and almost-looks. Sanchez put the biscuit in the basket in the 6th minute (offside!). Ana Gomes had a run at goal in the 15th minute (offside). Sanchez took a crack four minutes later that Arnold did well to block. Ryan Williams rang the crossbar in the 42nd minute – that’s probably the tallest blue spike towards the end of the first half.

In the second half…Jesus wept. Talk about nail-biting. The Damned walked the ball all around the Thorns penalty area from the second half restart until the 56th minute. Ten. Fucking. Minutes. Of nonstop possession, passing, darting runs…and nothing. No shots, not even a sniff; the Thorns packed behind the ball and, for once, the bus was parked right in the way of Carolina getting anywhere.

Still, Carolina had a long time to work something, and only one goal stood between them and the road point (and, needless to say, reducing Portland to a need-to-win-on-Decision-Day point as well). And, well, they worked something truly dangerous, beginning in the 70th minute, when substitute forward Gianna Paul drove to the byline, rounding substitute fullback M.A. Vignola, and slotted a low cross into Evelyn Ijeh, who had only Calzada and the keeper to beat.

FWIW, the player to watch on this one is Paul, down in the lower right corner. See her giving Ijah the “Go! Go! C’mon, bestie, go turn and crank it!!” signals? Okay; keep your side-eye on Paul.

Had Ijah the sort of touch that, say, Pietra Tordin has, she could have spun backwards to clear Calzada and then set herself up for a good chance to finish past Arnold to equalize.

But. I don’t see Ijeh enough to know whether she has those kind of skills. I can say with confidence that she sure didn’t have them last Sunday. Because, instead, Ijeh continued her run to the far top corner of the six with Calzada staying in front of her, and cranked a shot that just banged harmlessly off Calzada:

Remember I told you how the best part was watching Paul down in the corner. Well…

…okay. That’s fucking awesome; we all know that feeling, right? WTF? Seriously? You really did that? Well…fuckadoo.

Anyway, both possession (63%-37%) and passing (86% of 575 passes to 81% of 343) were ridiculously lopsided for Carolina, but the shots and xG point right back to the purposelessness of The Damned’s possession.

Lots of the ball, no idea what to do with it if Sanchez hero-ball doesn’t work. Uncomfortably familiar feeling, if a pleasant surprise to see it working for us, instead of against.

Carlisle-sensei with the passing plots. Portland:

I’m gonna be contrary here. I like a lot of what Turner does, and it wouldn’t shock me to see her, indeed, “put it all together”. But until then, the bottom line for forwards is goals scored. Until she can do that consistently, well…let’s add that it’d help a lot if she, like every other fucking Thorns forward (are you reading this, Coach? I’ll repeat it in Swedish if it’d help…) had second – and third! – options to dish to or to take the defensive pressure off her.

But to live up to her promise Turner needs to start finishing these attacks. She does so many other things so well! I keep coming back again and again to the disconnect between the quantity of attacking quality this club has and the number of times we see those attackers all alone, freelancing and trying to create chances by themselves rather than as part of a team.

The Damned:

I’m not worried! Anything bad that happens to The Damned Courage makes me smile.

But…yeah. What worried me about this one (from when Turner flamed out at about the quarter-hour until Muller’s hour strike) was that Carolina is the most prolific scoring club in the league this season with the prospective single-season individual scoring record on the roster and…the Thorns didn’t score or, again, outside Turner’s efforts, really looked much like scoring.

But after a run or two Gomes disappeared, and Ijeh’s only real chance was the one we’ve looked at above. No Sanchez? That left Williams (two shots off-target – since the crossbar is officially not on frame) and Riley Jackson’s one off-target shot.

That ain’t gonna feed the bulldog. Lucky for us.

Turnover and over.

Here’s how things are going;

Opponent – Venue (Result)Turnovers
Washington – Away (W)26
Seattle – Home (W)11
San Diego – Away (L)29
Kansas City – Home (W)23
North Carolina – Away (D)25
Angel City – Away (W)22
San Diego – Home (W)17
Chicago – Away (W)32
Louisville – Away (L)25
Angel City – Home (D)No data
Bay FC – Home (W)33
Kansas City – Away (L)29
Utah – Home (D)23
Louisville – Home (W)21
Seattle – Away (L)33
Denver – Away (L)33
Gotham – Home (D)23
Utah – Away (L)17
Boston – Away (W)17
Orlando – Home (W)24
Denver – Home (W)19
Gotham – Away (D)21
Washington – Home (L)23
Chicago – Home (D)18
Orlando – Away (W)22
Houston – Home (D)20
Boston – Home (L)33
Bay FC – Away (D)35
North Carolina – Home (w)23

Not terrific, but…better. Especially since The Damned were coughing up 24 at the same time. Plus the Thorns tightened up as Carolina were chasing; 15 giveaways before the break (to Carolina’s 10) but only 8 afterwards to Carolina’s 14).

Fleming was, rather shockingly, the Biggest Loser with an appalling six-and-a-half turnovers. Perry and Calzada gave away four each, but no one else coughed up more than two. The other positive is that none were particularly dangerous.

Press!

Twenty-eighth match tracking the press. I counted either a 1) turnover (either from a tackle-for-loss or a mishit forced pass), or a 2) forced retreat or drop-pass that killed off a progressive action, as a pressing “win”.

The press numbers reflect possession and style more than anything.

Neither side’s press was particularly effective. Portland pressed a shit-ton because that’s where the ball was – at Carolina’s feet – but was largely ineffective at it because the Thorns press is still a one-player-at-a-time/do-it-yourself kind of gimmick…

…and because of that is still painfully simple for a halfway-decent opponent to pass through, around…

…and out of.

Now this, on the other hand, is Carolina’s press. Notice how every red shirt is marked up almost touch tight?

Had Portland had any possession to speak of? Carolina’s press might have actually made some sort of impact. As it was the Damned were more a nuisance pressing than anything.

Match timeNCC presses (wins)(%)Thorns presses (wins)(%)
0-45+3′32(16) (50%)66(29) (43.9%)
45-90+3′27(14) (51.8%)29(13) (44.8%)
Match Total59(30) (50.8%)95(42) (44.2%)

My thoughts:
1) What I said above.
2) Hard to really generalize from this one, other than the usual observation that trying to figure out the Thorns tactics and doctrine is damn near impossible since, as the Soviet observers were supposed to have said about the U.S. Army, they don’t have any identifiable tactics or appear to follow any sort of consistent doctrine.

Here’s the running tally:

Match (Result)Opponent Press (Success)Thorns Press (Success)
Washington Away (W)40(27) (67.5%)69(41) (59.4%)
Seattle Home (W)61(30) (49.1%)35(20) (57.1%)
San Diego Away (L)33(22) (66.6%)88(40) (45.4%)
Kansas City Home (W)26(15) (57.6%)43(23) (53.4%)
North Carolina Away (D)35(22) (62.8%)56(26) (46.4%)
Angel City Away (W)52(37) (71.1%)61(32) (52.4%)
San Diego Home (W)45(71) (63.3%)45(80) (56.2%)
Chicago Away (W)68(34) (50%)97(51) (52.2%)
Louisville Away (L)101(70) (69.5%)62(35) (56.4%)
Angel City Home (D)No dataNo data
Bay FC Home (W)59(34) (57.6%)59(37) (62.7%)
Kansas City Away (L)52(29) (55.7%)34(20) (58.8%)
Utah Home (D)99(55) (55.5%)60(31) (51.6%)
Louisville Home (W)55(31) (56.3%)28(13) (46.4%)
Seattle Away (L)67(46) (68.6%)66(35) (53.0%)
Denver Away (L)46(24) (52.1%)53(27) (50.9%)
Gotham Home (D)60(32) (53.3%)58(86) (67.4%)
Utah Away (L)86(61) (70.9%)70(38) (54.2%)
Boston Away (W)84(55) (65.4%)83(44) (53%)
Orlando Home (w)94(57) (60.6%)87(55 (63.2%)
Denver Home (W)87(55) (63.2%)60(32) (53.3%)
Gotham Away (D)42(34) (80.9%)90(49) (54.4%)
Washington Home (L)43(30) (69.7%)64(35) (54.6%)
Chicago Home (D)42(27) (64.2%)54(33) (61.1%)
Orlando Away (W)38(29) (76.3%)39(23) (58.9%)
Houston Home (D)20(11) (55%)43(23) (53.4%)
Boston Home (L)36(20) (55.1%)53(23) (43.3%)
BayFC Away (D)42(25 (59.5%)81(40) (49.4%)
North Carolina Home (W)59(30) (50.8%)95(42) (44.2%)

Corner Kicks

Five. Two in the first half, three in the second. One short, four long.

TimeTakerShort/Long?Result
29′MullerLongInto the far edge of the scrum, and cleared.
33′MullerLongFound Calzada at the back post edge of the scrum, but Calzada was dispossessed.
58′MullerLongCalzada headed down but was called for a foul doing so.
86′MullerLongInto the scrum. Hannah Betfort headed it down to Reyes; her blocked shot bounded out to Hanks, who shot well over.
90+2′MullerShort…to Hanks in the near corner for some well-worked time-wasting.

No much, meaning more of same.

Player Ratings and Comments

Turner (+5/-1 : +2/-1 : +7/-2) Statistically Turner had the best Thorns chances of the match, which is fine. Didn’t finish any, which is not so much.

The bottom line is that Turner put in the work and helped her side get the result. We can discuss ways in which she might step up from there in the future, but last Sunday her ultimate task was to help her club secure the points and the playoffs, and she did, so good enough on the day.

Muller (+3/-1 : +2/-0 : +5/-1) Poster child for her squad in this match. Did just enough to get the win, which is either true genius or insanely lucky, but I’ll bet she’d take it either way. Ausgezeichnet!

Tordin (+1/-1 : +12/-1 : +13/-1) Exploded in the second half from near invisibility in the first; from skirmishing futilely at the fringes of the attack to becoming active and dangerous both going forward (seven of her second half pluses are for attacking play) and defending including pressing, intercepting passes, tackles and winning duels. Not sure who said what to whom at halftime, but who and whatever it woke Tordin the hell up, and well as…

Hanks (+3/-1 : +12/-2 : +15/-3) …who proceeded to do the same; attacked (seven of 12 second half pluses) and defended like a beast. With Carolina desperately needing a goal both forwards were essential to hanging on to the win, did, so well played.

Nijstad (+6/-1 : +6/-0 : +12/-1) Once again the double pivot seemed to hinge on one of the two pivots. This match it was Nina Nijstad carrying the defensive load; eight of her 12 pluses were for ball-winning presses or open-field duel wins.

Fleming (+3/-1 : +4/-2 : +7/-3) I’m not sure why these two are like this, but here we go again; Nijstad has a good match (9 “defensive contributions”, won 3 of 4 tackles, 2 interceptions, 3 clearances, 3 recoveries, won 6 of 12 ground duels and both aerial duels) and Fleming sort of sits back (3 defensive contributions, 0 tackles, 1 interception, 2 clearances, won only 2 of 5 ground duels and one in the air…though Fleming did recover 8 lost balls) and enjoys the ride.

Why are they like this? I don’t see anything on the pitch that jumps out at me, but their numbers always seem to be this way, lopsided one way or the other. It is a puzzlement.

Calzada (+7/-3 : +3/-1 : +10/-4) I can’t even imagine.

Coming off possibly her worst match as a Thorn, Coach Vilahamn handed Calzada the horrifying task of stopping the league’s Golden Boot as the starting right fullback.

To her credit, Calzada did just that. Didn’t put a foot wrong, kept Sanchez quiet all match. Big night in a big match. Well done, damn well done.

Obaze (61′ – +3/-1 : +0/-0 : +3/-1) The key to this match defensively was coordination and understanding in the backline and DMs, and so Carolina had few opportunities to isolate and beat a Thorns back one-on-one. Both Obaze and…

Vignola (29′ – +6/-3) …got maximum benefit from this group effort as well as playing important parts in it. So, despite the low numbers, a good outing for the backline in general and the individual backs in particular.

Perry (+2/-0 : +3/-0 : +5/-0) Same here.

Reyes (+4/-0 : +3/-1 : +7/-1) And here.

Arnold (+3/-0 : +2/-0 : +5/-0) Not tested very often (thanks to her backs and DMs, mostly, but also by The Damned being utterly adrift for much of the match) but that just makes her big saves off Sanchez – 19th minute and 62nd minute blocks – look even bigger.

Coach Vilahamn: Got the dub and the playoffs without really changing my mind any regarding the club’s way forward.

Against The Damned playing for a one-goal/clean sheet win? I’m sorry, but unless he had some secret intel we didn’t that’s somewhere between “insanely optimistic” and “just nuts”.

But regardless of whether he was genius or madman, the gaffer’s plan worked to unlock Thorns Level One. His club will get an a first round playoff match.

Now – after a brief Texas vacation – the hard work really begins.

John Lawes
Latest posts by John Lawes (see all)

10 thoughts on “Thorns FC: Goals change games. LOTS of games.”

  1. Did this game play out exactly as the Thorns, particularly Vilahamn, intended? It sure looked like we intended to defend and counter. But defend-and-counter games are sometimes forced on you by a technically superior opponent, when you just can’t retain possession and your only option, on the rare occasions you do get the ball, is to score quickly before it gets taken away. If I had to say, I’d guess that Vilahamn used the tactic intentionally this game, just because the Courage aren’t that dominant a team in possession; we could have possessed more if we had tried to. If so, kudos to him for setting it up. As you say, it was case of “the Damned being utterly adrift for much of the match”, and I always say that the sign of a good defense is that the opposing offense “has a bad day.” Any time Ashley Sanchez is so utterly shut down, the Courage has had a bad day. Props to the defense too for executing it so well.

    In addition I wonder if the Nijstad/Fleming difference was also because of Sanchez. NC kept trying to work the ball to her, and that was Nijstad’s side of the field so she got involved a lot more. This is just a thought, not anything backed up by facts yet; I haven’t actually rewatched any of the game with this in mind.

    0
    1. So I’m guessing that Vilahamn did, indeed, figure that rope-a-doping The Damned was their best option. I think the plan was to fire Turner forward to nick the early goal and then park the bus in front of Sanchez.

      That seems pretty risky. Our defending hasn’t been particularly sturdy, and our ability to score on demand hasn’t been much in evidence, and wasn’t last Sunday; I’m not sure what the odds of that game ending in a scoreless draw were, but I wouldn’t have been shocked if it had, and Carolina’s failure to score owed as much to their own mistakes (see: Ijeh at 70′) as our own defending.

      That said, the point is that it DID work, and we’re in a quarterfinal. The job now is to do a Gotham; get hot for three games straight. Can we do that? Hmmm…

      I’m not sure that Nijstad got the mark-Sanchez assignment. It looked to me like Sanchez mostly tried driving the left touchline where it was Calzada who got tangled up with her as much or more than any of the other Thorns, tho it’s not impossible that the left-side attacks pulled Nijstad in, too, so…dunno. But this has been a long-running pattern; whichever side of the double pivot gets hot means the other gets a day off, so maybe it was just that. Dunno for sure.

      0
  2. Lo, it is written in the Book of Fotmob, Chapter 10, Verse 23: “xGOT 0.55 Thorns, 0.78 Damned.” Here endeth the epistle, amen. 😅

    Someone must have lit a fire under CC because holy smokes did that woman turn on the heat. I don’t know if she was doing penance or just hungry.

    Petition to start calling MM “die Donnerkeilin” or something. We can workshop it. 🤭

    0
    1. Thank you for the PSxG numbers. Updated the post, and that just makes me less blithe about accepting Vilahamn’s rope-a-dope “plan”. Without Muller’s golazo the chance of a scoreless draw looks extremely likely.

      “Little Thunder” (Die Donnerkleine)? I think the original German would be more like “kleines Donnermadchen” (little thunder girl), but, yeah, I get the idea.

      0
      1. I was going for the feminine -in ending on “thunderbolt”.

        Something I find curious is that the xGOT on Müller’s golazo was only 0.18. Which seems to me to be implying that Sheridan should’ve gotten to it. And indeed she did get her fingers on it – it just wasn’t enough.

        0
        1. IIRC the primary factor for xG/xGOT is location of the shot. Elements like situation (turnover/breakaway) or striking method (header) play a role, but the spot from which the ball is launched is the biggest single input. Muller’s launching pad – outside the 18 – isn’t quite the lowest possible value…but it’s close.

          So that kind of points up what a close-call-to-a-scoreless-draw this one was, and what a golazo that thunderbolt was. It was just a flat-out terrific goal.

          0
  3. Thanks for the write up. The Thorns deserved some Roses after that performance. Does that game put me back on my ridiculously optimistic horse? Nope, but I see some hope for next year. I still see a lot of upside for Perry and hey CC has wheels! Now if she can add more defensive nous to that natural speed, she could wind up being a good one.
    The Fleming/Nijstad lopsided numbers is weird, but despite that, both are hard workers and Nijstad made a full 90 in this game; so that was a big plus.
    Turner looked great for most of the first half. She is fast and she is an athlete, but in that game she took to many touches in the box and allowed the defenders to stop her. Hope she works on that.
    As I replied to Thornado’s Fot Mob dump of statistics on STF, this Thorns team is realistically only a mid table team and I think if they can improve their possession it will help so much next year. Soph had a bad year of finishing. The inexperienced duo of Perry and Calzada were exposed and they still need a 6, but for me I am hopeful about next year.

    0
    1. The baseball writer Bill James had what I thought was the most applicable comment on the whole “wait’ll next year” thing (in a post about baseball manager Billy Martin): “Tomorrow may be a dream, or a nightmare, or may never be.”

      I’m not sure it’s really realistic to speculate on what we’re going to see in March and April 2027. Contracts, injuries, roster building, team cohesion, coaching…there’s just too many moving parts to really predict how this club will roll out in half a year.

      Which is to say that it’s fine to be optimistic, but it’s also reasonable to be patient and see that happens at the end of this season and in the off-season. On Opening Day we’ll see what we look like, and hopefully that will be a good look…

      1
  4. Thanks for posting the “Behind the Tifo” shot, John. For once I actually responded to the “rate your experience” email after the game, to suggest they stop ruining everyone’s views of the Tifos with their stupid fireworks.

    Probably not appropriately global epicenteristic of me. But from what little I could see of it, that one looked (possibly?) pretty good.

    0
    1. You weren’t the only one to complain about the smoke, which from what I could see of the photos WAS extremely thick and lingered a longer time than usual. I don’t actually “get” the club’s enthusiasm for pyrotechnics at every occasion. Playoffs? Sure! Opening Day/Closing Day (which this kinda was…). Fine. But c’mon. Do we really need the bombs bursting in air EVERY match..?

      And let me put in a plug for the tifo-crows’ inspiration; “Wildwood” is a genuinely brilliant film, from the visuals to the story at the center, which is touchingly heart-rending, kind of an astounding accomplishment for a flick composed of stop-motion sequences made of clay figurines.

      I’m kinda prejudiced, tho; Prue and her movie family “live” in the Wildwood version of my hometown, St. Johns, and there’s a lot of scenery I kept recognizing from around here – “Hey! That’s the clock next to the U.S. Bank! That’s the railroad bridge across from The Cut!” which just made it more fun…

      0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.